Left Icon
Left Icon Open
Big Daddy?

Navigation

Collapse all Button

Contributions or comments related to this page?

» Email us

Last Updated:

» September 16, 2025
Archived Dissection
Originally published at SpaceBattles Forums. May 19th, 2011. Big Daddy?. Tract #015. Art by Jack Chick - © 1970 Chick Publications

Originally published at SpaceBattles Forums
May 10th, 2011


 
Cover / Page 1

Big Daddy? - Tract #015 (BIGD)
Art by Jack Chick- © 1970 Chick Publications


A student proves evolution is full of holes.

CommentatorsCommentators

Harbinger

Harbinger

 
Page Index
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

o Introduction collapse_button

HarbingerHarbinger Once again at risk of doing this when not wanted by FS, I decided to do another one. It's kind of a tough one to do without being boring, but still it's another one of my favorites. As a forewarning I look at this from the perspective of a history student who took a few anthropology, biology, and physics courses in college. Also wikipedia. So without further ado, I present Big Daddy.

 

o Cover / Page 1 collapse_button

Cover / Page 1
 
HarbingerHarbinger Eh, not quite.

 

o Page 2 collapse_button

Page 2
 
HarbingerHarbinger And here we enter a university classroom of a 198- *looks at publish date* 2002 apparently. Our professor, the fugly antagonist asks a question that all those damn liberal college professors always do. Though he hasn't stated his opinion the fact that this guy has a picture of an ape captioned 'our father' seems to point us in the direction of his beliefs.

 

o Page 3 collapse_button

Page 3
 
HarbingerHarbinger And now are class, which consist of a bunch of bleating sheep and one champion of all that is good in the world. You'd think those other students would have opinions of their own, but throughout the comic all they do is agree or disagree with our belligerents, like the crowd cheering on a street fight.

 

o Page 4 collapse_button

Page 4
 
HarbingerHarbinger Seriously, look at the guy! Sure, pince-nez are always cool, but a bad comb-over, the almost donkey like teeth, hell the goatee!

And of course if anyone disagrees with him he immediately kicks them out of the class. Did I have the only tolerant anthropology professor in college? I'd hate to see what this guy's student evaluations are like. Then again, since the rest of the class has no opinion of their own then he's probably golden.


 

o Page 5 collapse_button

Page 5
 
HarbingerHarbinger Good lord I hope this guy doesn't have tenure. Then again considering some of the professors I've had I wouldn't be surprised.

So now we get a good look at our hero, a gentlemanly, almost Aryan young man. He's so very polite and kind compared to the obviously evil professor. Oh right and the rest of the class is making snarky comments in the background.


 

o Page 6 collapse_button

Page 6
 
HarbingerHarbinger Look out! He's about to so Super Saiyan!

This must be the evil atheist world (or Catholic I really wouldn't be surprised) where being religious is apparently against the law. I only say this because I made mention of my beliefs to my anthropology professor when I took some classes and she really didn't care.

Ah, but this man worships at the alter of SCIENCE!, which makes sense. After all SCIENCE! is so much fun to say. You can't get the same effect out of RELIGION Oh and if anyone has any allergies you might want to back out now because like Freudian Slip's last tract we are about to have a huge straw man set up here.


 

o Page 7 collapse_button

Page 7
 
HarbingerHarbinger And here we see our first example: Since everyone teaches it, then it must be true. Because that's how SCIENCE! works.

And to be honest I'd probably be questioning my teacher if he started screaming like that. I'd probably back slowly out of the classroom and request a transfer to another class, maybe get the campus police to haul him away. The guy obviously has some anger issues.


 

o Page 8 collapse_button

Page 8
 
HarbingerHarbinger Hmm...you know for this I'll have to turn to my good friend and assistant Morbo. Morbo?

Thank you Morbo. Again I must reiterate I hope this guy doesn't have tenure. And surprise Professor Strawman, that's not how evolution works! Here let me, the invisible student in the class who's too busy screwing around on his laptop to participate in the conversation define evolution. And this is off the top of my head mind you: Any change in genetic allele frequencies in a population over time. In this context it applies only to biology.

What you think is chemical evolution? We have a word for that, it's called fusion. We can do it, it's proven.

Planetary evolution? It's called a nebular hypothesis (see that word? It'll come up in real science a lot. It's not set in stone), and I'm pretty sure it's been observed.

Organic evolution? Eh...Well...Life from rocks? Oh for christ's sake, Morbo?

Thank you Morbo. You know I think that applies to everything else listed. Anyway, most of those have already been observed or are called something entirely different. Now a man who has studied this all his life and undoubtedly has a Phd on the subject would know this. I don't know maybe this is a shitty community college or something. Moving on.


 

o Page 9 collapse_button

Page 9
 
HarbingerHarbinger Wait, aren't Neanderthals only tangentially related to modern man? In fact I'm pretty sure that by 2002 we knew that we did not evolve from the Neanderthals. Professor Strawman I hope you're just setting up this student to say something stupid. But you're a Jack Chick character, of course you're not.

And of course Darwin is mentioned. Actually I'm kind of amazed. I think this is the only time Darwin is mentioned in this whole tract. I guess he had to be stuck in there somewhere.


 

o Page 10 collapse_button

Page 10
 
HarbingerHarbinger Well I'll throw Jack a bone here since Ardi wasn't published until 2009.

But this rebuttal. Okay I'll spare Morbo this time, but I haven't been able to find any information about Leakey's human skull discovery (though I am only using wikipedia here), but I did find some information about his discovery of a homo habilis and homo erectus skull. Interesting to leave those out.

And yes, Lucy was just a chimp, a chimp with legs meant for walking upright, and with a lumbar curve in her spine, which is part of the reason we can walk upright. Oh and she had a larger cranial capacity than chimps. And...yeah me thinks someone didn't do his research. Well surely Professor Strawman will be able to explain this to our student to clear up this misunderstanding.

It's also funny how the student basically shoots his argument in the foot by admitting the Earth is more than 6000 years old.


 

o Page 11 collapse_button

Page 11
 
HarbingerHarbinger Goddammit Professor Strawman. Come on does Jack really think that the way of naming these finds are important to proving or disproving evolution? Here's a hint Lucy was named because Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds was playing when they brought the skeleton into camp.

Oh ho, but the student obviously has a scientific study of his own. And surely SCIENCE! has the answers!


 

o Page 12 collapse_button

Page 12
 
HarbingerHarbinger ...
...
...
Morbo?

Because don't mention Australopithecus, Homo Habilis, Homo Erectus, or... I think you have the idea.

You know, I am really beginning to feel sorry for his co-anchor. Hm...Ah I've got it!


 

o Page 13 collapse_button

Page 13
 
HarbingerHarbinger YOU MORON, YOU MENTIONED CARBON 14 SEVERAL PAGES AGO. BRING UP THAT, OR SOME OTHER FORM OF RADIOMETRIC DATING. HOW ABOUT EARLY STONE AGE TOOLS THAT ARE DATED AT MILLIONS OF YEARS OLD. FOR GOD'S SAKE MAN HOW DID YOU GET A DEGREE IN WHATEVER IT IS THAT YOU TEACH!

Sorry, got a bit carried away there.


 

o Page 14 collapse_button

Page 14
 
HarbingerHarbinger Oh now I get it! Professor Strawman gets all of his information from sources over a century old! Because since such information is most certainly not in modern textbooks this must be the case. Man, I though the US university system was good, but here they're still selling outdated textbooks, and I bet they still charge around $150 dollars for it. Oh well, keep at it professor! You have him on the ropes!

 

o Page 15 collapse_button

Page 15
 
HarbingerHarbinger Once more Professor Strawman uses outdated knowledge to prove SCIENCE! correct. Has anyone noticed that he loves to say individual pieces of evidence decisively prove his argument? Wait, this is 2002 so maybe he's just treating this like an internet argument. That'd explain a lot. Mind you some humans have been born with vestigial tails. Yeah don't bring that up Jack. I'm sure whoever reads these things never bothers to research much on their own.

 

o Page 16 collapse_button

Page 16
 
HarbingerHarbinger What does this guy teach anyway? He's going all over the place.

I love the second panel as well with the student towering over the cowering professor while stating a wrong definition of evolution.. I think we all know what this calls for!


 

o Page 17 collapse_button

Page 17
 
HarbingerHarbinger Again, any change in genetic allele frequencies in a population over time. Despite claims by many there's really no such thing as de-evolution. Some genetic changes simply do not work. Such creatures have a tendency to die out over time because of it.

 

o Page 18 collapse_button

Page 18
 
HarbingerHarbinger Ooohh! And the student is on the attack! And Professor Strawman replies with a...well that's actually a correct answer. Jack's heroic student ignores that gluons have been observed and goes on about. Okay Morbo I think you know the drill...

 

o Page 19 collapse_button

Page 19
 
HarbingerHarbinger Yes, let's ignore the neutrons because they have absolutely nothing to do with holding the nucleus of an atom together. Because there's no such force that could possibly have an effect on the interaction between protons and neutrons. Because adding or removing neutrons does absolutely nothing to an atom. Yes I know I'm using Wikipedia, but this was made in 2002. If I have access to it so did Jack Chick.

And thus we see Professor Strawman finally break down. Poor guy, he put up a valiant effort. But when your only knowledge comes from Jack Chick's knowledge of science then you really don't have much of a chance.


 

o Page 20 collapse_button

Page 20
 
HarbingerHarbinger ...I'd call out Morbo, but I'm not sure he could cover this. Remember boys and girls, God holds together atoms. Now...okay as someone who believes in God (*gasp* I know! Crazy isn't it!) I tend to believe that God created not just the universe, but all of the natural forces and laws that govern it. So...yeah scientific explanation for why things work the way they do make total and complete sense! Holy crap! Stop the presses! Blasphemy! Well at least it is according to Jack Chick.

And so exits Professor Strawman, thus being proven completely and totally wrong about evolution. Decades of research all undone by a single conversation with a student.


 

o Page 21 collapse_button

Page 21
 
HarbingerHarbinger Thankfully Professor Strawman's colleagues have been reading up and are up to date on the latest research concerning evolutionary theory. So he loses tenure probably, that stupid picture is smashed, and he's probably given several books to read before he's allowed back into the classroom. Maybe Richard Dawkins is called up to guest lecture in the interim.

 

o Page 22 collapse_button

Page 22
 
HarbingerHarbinger And our heroic student is left alone in a room full of gullible idiots so he does what he does best.

Final thoughts...Morbo?

I kind of have to disagree with you on that. I've had a few stupid professors, well one really sticks out and she was a history professor. Even then she knew her specialization, just nothing else. So, okay yeah I agree. I wonder if that university needs a new paleontology professor? I only have a BA in History, but considering their qualification standards I think I have a good shot.


 

o Conclusion collapse_button

HarbingerHarbinger Placeholder Text

 

o Further Reading collapse_button


 

o Other Reviews & Commentaries collapse_button

 

o Parodies collapse_button